Category Archives: Suicide Assessment and Intervention

Meet Virginia (the powerpoints from VCA and VCU)

I’ve been in Virginia at the Virginia Counseling Association conference in Norfolk and now at Virginia Commonwealth University in Richmond.

This post includes my ppts from four presentations in pdf format. If you were at VCA, please accept my apologies for the delay in getting these posted.

Here they are,

VCA Keynote:

VCA Breakout 1:

VCA Breakout 2:

VCU Public Lecture:

The Best Suicide Prevention Questionnaires. . . and Upcoming Events

An online friend in Richmond, Virginia with a mutual interest in suicide prevention emailed asking a question about my perspective on using assessment questionnaires to conduct suicide risk assessments.

She shared a post from a listserv called PAUSE (People Addressing and Understanding Suicide Experiences). The PAUSE post used Gemini to explore the question: “How effective is the C-SSRS (aka “the Columbia”) in predicting and eliminating false positives in individual risk assessment situations?”

Gemini’s AI discussion was fascinating—in all the ways you might imagine. 

Gemini led with the basic truth that suicide prediction suffers from the statistical “Low base rate problem.” The low frequency (or low base rate) of death by suicide in the general population makes it nearly impossible to predict without having too many false positives. A false positive in suicide assessment is when someone is identified as “high risk” for suicide, but the true risk is not high. Because the U.S. has about 14 suicide deaths per 100,000 people, prediction efforts tend to produce a plethora of false positives, making accurate predictions difficult.

The bigger problem in suicide assessment and screening is the problem of the false negatives. Gemini wasn’t asked about false negatives and didn’t go there. A false negative occurs when the instrument or clinician concludes “low risk” when, in fact, risk is high. This is a bigger problem because false negatives can lead to death whereas false positives lead to overidentification or unnecessary intervention. This bigger problem may be why Craig Bryan advises against using instruments to categorize risk. Because death by suicide is often driven by acute variables (e.g., a relationship break-up, intoxication, job loss, etc.), categorizing anyone as “low risk” based on a screening or assessment will result in too many cases where suicidality is tragically underestimated.

I’d love to dive deeper into questionnaires, actuarial vs. clinical assessment, and the science of predicting human behavior (which was the topic of my Master’s thesis and Doctoral dissertation). However, I’m stopping here because I don’t want to go down the same road as Gemini. . .which is a road with lots of information and statistics and that almost COMPLETELY MISSES THE POINT. What is the point? Suicide assessment questionnaires never prevent suicide.

I should put that statement in ALL BOLD CAPS. To repeat:

SUICIDE ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRES NEVER PREVENT SUICIDE.

Suicide assessment questionnaires are tools that help, but they cannot save lives. Suicide assessments must be used by clinicians; clinicians are the driving force in prevention and saving lives. Here’s another point that deserves bolding and all caps.

ONLY CLINICIANS, FRIENDS, COWORKERS, FAMILY, OR OTHER HUMANS PREVENT SUICIDE AND SAVE LIVES.

As much as I love exploring statistics, science, and prediction all these fascinating concepts cannot replace human connection, trusting relationships, and skills-based interventions.  Suicide assessment questionnaires, checklists, and screenings are tools. That’s all.

Since way back in the 1970s, the general rule in the world of psychological assessment has been that actuarial based assessment is a better prediction tool than clinician assessment. This is probably still true, but when we’re talking about human behavior and suicide, the answer is sometimes “it depends.”

So. . . “Which suicide questionnaire is the best for predicting and preventing suicide?” Although I think questionnaire validity and reliability are important, in the case of suicide assessment, the underlying statistics are nearly irrelevant. What’s relevant is whether a specific clinician can use a specific questionnaire to connect with, care for, and effectively a specific person who is suicidal.

Assessment instruments and efforts to accurately predict suicide risk are so intellectually fascinating that we often risk missing the point. Suicide prevention is extremely difficult, suicide prediction is extremely difficult, and the success of prediction and prevention efforts depend almost completely on human interaction.

Thanks for reading.

In case you’re interested—and especially for my Virginia and Alabama friends—this week I’ll be in Virginia doing three presentations at the Virginia Counseling Association conference in Norfolk, VA on Thursday, November 12.

https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.vcacounselors.org/resource/resmgr/2026_vca_convention/2026_VCA_Convention_Program.pdf

Next week I’ll be at Virginia Commonwealth University on Monday November 16.

Then I’ll be at the Bon Air Library in Richmond doing a suicide-related Lunch N’ Learn on Tuesday, November 17 (see above).

On Thursday, November 19, I’ll be in Mobile, Alabama doing two presentations at the Alabama Counseling Association.

https://www.alabamacounseling.org/uploads/1/2/3/9/123960750/2026_alca_new_brochureflyer.pdf

Big thanks go to Robert Froelich of VCA, Waganesh Zeleke of VCU, Erin Gallagher of Jay Walkers, and Daniel Birdsong of ALCA for organizing all these events.

The MHA Suicide Prevention Summit is Free (up to 20 CEUs) and Coming Soon!

Why should you know about the Mental Health Academy’s annual Suicide Prevention summit?

It’s big. There are luminaries (e.g., David Jobes, Stacey Freedenthal, and Rory O’Connor). It’s free. And the MHA is an amazing Australian-based organization that gives as good as it gets. On their website, they report:

Supporting local initiatives
Through partnering with leading organizations around the world, we’ve been able to support local initiatives we’re passionate about, including helping prevent child abuse and suicide, expanding mental health services to communities in need, and more.
$1.7M given since 2009

As a part of the annual Suicide Prevention Summit, this coming Sunday, at 10:30am Eastern, August 23, 2026, I’ll be presenting. My talk is titled: “The Bad News Brain: Five Psychological Truths on Why It’s So Damn Hard to Focus on the Positive.”

Did I mention that this whole summit is free? You can get up to 20 CEUs. You can also pay $20 to have access to session recordings until October 18.

Here’s a link to the whole schedule, which begins Wednesday, August 19 at 7pm Eastern, with a presentation by David Jobes. In case you don’t know, Jobes is awesome.
https://d9hv9sikl36u8.cloudfront.net/documents/MHA-USA-SPS-2026-Schedule-V1.pdf

Not only is the live version of this event free, all the presenters also present for free.

Sometimes, when presenting online to large groups, like the Summit, it’s hard to know how the presentation is being received. This is especially true for webinar-style presentations where there’s no interaction other than the “chat feed.” The problem with using the chat feed for feedback is that it’s overwhelming. Trying to split my attention between doing my talk and reading participant comments requires repeated figure-ground shifts that render my brain dysfunctional. Consequently, I only focus on talking, ignore the feed, and wait for the illustrious Pedro Gondim to facilitate Q&R during the final 10 minutes.

Last time I presented at the Summit, a very kind, smart, and talented mental health professional I know happened to be in attendance. She wrote me a very short Dear John email:

See attached!
I have never seen anything close to this in terms of the outpouring of appreciation for you. 

All by itself, her email made my day. But she also attached the chat feed. I opened it and found a gift of 449 amazing comments. I was stunned and humbled.

This blog post is a reminder that you can still sign up for the Summit. MHA will use a portion of the funds they generate from the $20 registrants to give back to local communities. I hope to see you there—even though I won’t really see you.

Just in case you’re curious, here’s a link to the whole 449 chat feed responses (with last names of commenters deleted).


 

Strengths-Based Suicide for Community Medical Center in Missoula

All too early tomorrow morning I’ll be doing a couple presentations for medical staff at the Community Medical Center in Missoula. Despite the early hour, I look forward to some interesting and useful conversations with the staff. This link is to a very long ppt slide deck. It’s long because the two groups with which I will work are small, and so I will do portions of the slides depending on what the groups would like to cover. Here’s a pdf of the ppts!

More Thoughts on Suicide Prediction and Suicide Screening (from Craig Bryan, Ph.D.)

Hi All,

Below, I’ve a pasted LinkedIn post from Dr. Craig Bryan, author of “Rethinking Suicide” and a leading suicide researcher. At the bottom of his comments there’s a link to the article of which he speaks.

Enjoy!

*****************

From Craig Bryan, LinkedIn – 6/29/2026

We keep trying to predict who will attempt suicide. A 15-year study suggests we’re asking the wrong question.

Researchers followed 2,060 Brazilian children from age 10 into their mid-twenties—one of the longest prospective suicide studies ever conducted outside a high-income country. They measured genetics, perinatal history, family psychiatric illness, childhood adversity, cognition, and clinical symptoms, then tested all of it together against who later attempted suicide.

The result: even with multiple domains of risk factors combined, prediction accuracy stayed modest (AUC 0.665), barely above the ceiling seen across 50 years of suicide research. More sophisticated machine learning models didn’t do any better than simple logistic regression.

Three factors stood out as consistent, actionable, and population-relevant: childhood threat exposure (especially bullying), caregiver history of suicide attempts, and childhood externalizing disorders. Bullying alone accounted for the largest share of preventable risk in the entire study.

The authors’ conclusion is blunt: distal childhood risk factors will likely never predict individual suicide attempts with precision, because suicide is driven by acute, fast-moving processes that a baseline assessment can’t capture. Trying to screen our way to safety has a ceiling. We hit it decades ago.

The better investment may not be sharper prediction. It may be quieter, structural prevention like anti-bullying programs, supporting parents with histories of suicidal behavior, and early identification of behavioral disorders, the kind of intervention that helps a population, whether or not we ever know which child needed it most.

**************************

Here’s the article link: https://lnkd.in/eRWtBiXK

I’m excited about Dr. Bryan’s post not because of the difficulties with prediction (which we’ve long know), but because of the idea of moving upstream toward structural prevention. I also feel this fits really well with what we’re trying to do with CAPE.

Obviously, I love this quotation: “Trying to screen our way to safety has a ceiling. We hit it decades ago.”

Have a great evening!

JSF

How to Grow Wellbeing in Teachers and Schools

I’m at the Office of Public Instruction Summer Institute in Bozeman today (and tomorrow), along with the Pirate and the Pusher. The Summer Institute is an annual four days of training for Montana educators.

Shortly after arriving, two women sitting at a table stared at me, looked away, and then stopped me as I walked by, saying, with enthusiasm, “We just took your class!”

They were, of course, referring to our Happiness for Educators course. Although completely online, I’m presenting in many of the videos, sometimes in my pajamas. We were all excited to meet in person.

They also got to meet Dylan Wright (who plays the role of a pirate in our Happiness for Educators course). I mean, how can you have a Happiness for Educators course without a pirate? They also met Tammy Tolleson Knee, the new and fabulous director of the Phyllis J. Washington Center for the Advancement of Positive Education at the University of Montana and high leverage “Pusher” of all things positive.

Tomorrow will be even more excitement. I have the honor of delivering the morning keynote. I’ll be opening with a make-believe scenario, with me as a candidate for governor. I’ve done this a few times previously during presentations for educators. It’s a method I use for emphasizing the central and foundational role that educators and education play in society.

My platform as a candidate for governor of Montana is education . . . education . . . and education . . . because. . .

The road to a good economy goes through education.

The road to a healthy enviroment goes through education.

The road to a civil society goes through education.

The road to excellence in health care goes through education.

The road to justice goes through education.

I could go on, but I think you get the point. As John Adams, founding father and our 2nd president once said (I’m paraphrasing), “It’s impossible to spend too much money on public education.”

And so, yes, there will be more excitement tomorrow because it doesn’t get much better than spending a day with 400 Montana educators who are dedicated to helping young people become educated citizens.

I’m posting ppts of my two presentations (keynote and workshop) below.

The Secret Retreat

Yesterday, Tammy Tolleson Knee (the new director of the Phyllis J. Washington Center for the Advancement of Positive Education) and I arrived in Kalispell, Montana for a 2+ day retreat with staff from the Nate Chute Foundation (NCF). Their mission: The Nate Chute Foundation supports, educates and empowers our community to promote mental wellness and reduce suicide. You can learn more about NCF’s fabulous work and staff right here: https://www.natechutefoundation.org/

Our retreat is top secret, but I’ll share it here anyway because I don’t like secrets.

Having grown weary with traditional, pathology-oriented approaches to “suicide prevention” we’re working together to create a new curriculum tentatively titled “Strengths-Based Suicide Education for Concerned Adults.” Our plan is to use this new curriculum to replace all the unhelpful and sometimes traumatizing approaches to suicide prevention.

Yes, we have big goals.

Today we’re breaking away from our retreat for a short presentation/consult with Immanuel Living of Kalispell.

In preparation for this short conversation, I pulled out an old slide about a thing called Stress Inoculation Training (thanks Don Meichenbaum!).

The point of SIT is to prepare for stressors or provocations in life that adversely affect us. For example, let’s say that you find ___________ stressful. (You can put anything in the blank. It could be exercise, talking with your boss, going to church, not going to church, speaking in public meetings, etc.). Then you create your own personalized stress inoculation plan.

Meichenbaum’s therapy approach is designed to prep or inoculate us from our usual and predictable stressors. He described three steps: (1) preparation for provocation, (2) coping with the provocative situation, and (3) reflection and self-reinforcement. Here’s a visual, with our stressors and responses organized into 7 dimensions:

If we all had rational brains and lived in a rational world, SIT would work perfectly for everyone. But like everything, it doesn’t always work. During today’s talk, I’m revealing the secrets of why our best laid plans often fail. Newsflash: it has to do with our quirky brains, which, although amazing, also automatically and regularly take us down into negative thinking rabbit holes.

TBH, IMHO, dipping into a negative thinking rabbit hole every once in a while can be fun, but if your intention was to avoid negative thinking rabbit holes, they’re considerably less fun.

Unfortunately, due to time limits and the need for mystery in marketing, this blog is ending without me sharing the five secrets of why our pesky brains often derail us from our positive intentions. Sorry about that. They’re in the pdf of the ppts linked below, and although you can find them there, it’s much more fun for us to talk about these in person . . . so I hope to see you at a presentation in the future.

Free Online Workshop and CEU Alert: “Strengths-Based Suicide Assessment and Treatment”

Thanks to the generosity of the Maryland Department of Health and the University of Maryland School of Medicine, I’ll be offering a free two-hour online training on Thursday, April 30 from 10am-noon (Eastern time). The flyer (attached below) includes details on the workshop content and a QR code for registering.

I hope to see you online on April 30.

2026 ACA World Conference: Strengths-Based Suicide

Along with Kimberly Parrow, this morning I have the privilege of offering a 3-hour workshop at the 2026 ACA Annual Conference.

As always, this is a challenging topic. But in the spirit of a strengths-based approach, it’s important to remember that by engaging in this learning together, we make ourselves stronger, more capable, and more prepared to help clients and students who are feeling suicidal.

Thanks to ACA for the opportunity, to Kim for the help, and for the attendees for being rockstars who are dedicated to helping individuals who are experiencing immense emotional pain and struggling with suicide. You are amazing.

The ppts in pdf: