Category Archives: Counseling and Psychotherapy Theory and Practice

The Best Suicide Prevention Questionnaires. . . and Upcoming Events

An online friend in Richmond, Virginia with a mutual interest in suicide prevention emailed asking a question about my perspective on using assessment questionnaires to conduct suicide risk assessments.

She shared a post from a listserv called PAUSE (People Addressing and Understanding Suicide Experiences). The PAUSE post used Gemini to explore the question: “How effective is the C-SSRS (aka “the Columbia”) in predicting and eliminating false positives in individual risk assessment situations?”

Gemini’s AI discussion was fascinating—in all the ways you might imagine. 

Gemini led with the basic truth that suicide prediction suffers from the statistical “Low base rate problem.” The low frequency (or low base rate) of death by suicide in the general population makes it nearly impossible to predict without having too many false positives. A false positive in suicide assessment is when someone is identified as “high risk” for suicide, but the true risk is not high. Because the U.S. has about 14 suicide deaths per 100,000 people, prediction efforts tend to produce a plethora of false positives, making accurate predictions difficult.

The bigger problem in suicide assessment and screening is the problem of the false negatives. Gemini wasn’t asked about false negatives and didn’t go there. A false negative occurs when the instrument or clinician concludes “low risk” when, in fact, risk is high. This is a bigger problem because false negatives can lead to death whereas false positives lead to overidentification or unnecessary intervention. This bigger problem may be why Craig Bryan advises against using instruments to categorize risk. Because death by suicide is often driven by acute variables (e.g., a relationship break-up, intoxication, job loss, etc.), categorizing anyone as “low risk” based on a screening or assessment will result in too many cases where suicidality is tragically underestimated.

I’d love to dive deeper into questionnaires, actuarial vs. clinical assessment, and the science of predicting human behavior (which was the topic of my Master’s thesis and Doctoral dissertation). However, I’m stopping here because I don’t want to go down the same road as Gemini. . .which is a road with lots of information and statistics and that almost COMPLETELY MISSES THE POINT. What is the point? Suicide assessment questionnaires never prevent suicide.

I should put that statement in ALL BOLD CAPS. To repeat:

SUICIDE ASSESSMENT QUESTIONNAIRES NEVER PREVENT SUICIDE.

Suicide assessment questionnaires are tools that help, but they cannot save lives. Suicide assessments must be used by clinicians; clinicians are the driving force in prevention and saving lives. Here’s another point that deserves bolding and all caps.

ONLY CLINICIANS, FRIENDS, COWORKERS, FAMILY, OR OTHER HUMANS PREVENT SUICIDE AND SAVE LIVES.

As much as I love exploring statistics, science, and prediction all these fascinating concepts cannot replace human connection, trusting relationships, and skills-based interventions.  Suicide assessment questionnaires, checklists, and screenings are tools. That’s all.

Since way back in the 1970s, the general rule in the world of psychological assessment has been that actuarial based assessment is a better prediction tool than clinician assessment. This is probably still true, but when we’re talking about human behavior and suicide, the answer is sometimes “it depends.”

So. . . “Which suicide questionnaire is the best for predicting and preventing suicide?” Although I think questionnaire validity and reliability are important, in the case of suicide assessment, the underlying statistics are nearly irrelevant. What’s relevant is whether a specific clinician can use a specific questionnaire to connect with, care for, and effectively a specific person who is suicidal.

Assessment instruments and efforts to accurately predict suicide risk are so intellectually fascinating that we often risk missing the point. Suicide prevention is extremely difficult, suicide prediction is extremely difficult, and the success of prediction and prevention efforts depend almost completely on human interaction.

Thanks for reading.

In case you’re interested—and especially for my Virginia and Alabama friends—this week I’ll be in Virginia doing three presentations at the Virginia Counseling Association conference in Norfolk, VA on Thursday, November 12.

https://cdn.ymaws.com/www.vcacounselors.org/resource/resmgr/2026_vca_convention/2026_VCA_Convention_Program.pdf

Next week I’ll be at Virginia Commonwealth University on Monday November 16.

Then I’ll be at the Bon Air Library in Richmond doing a suicide-related Lunch N’ Learn on Tuesday, November 17 (see above).

On Thursday, November 19, I’ll be in Mobile, Alabama doing two presentations at the Alabama Counseling Association.

https://www.alabamacounseling.org/uploads/1/2/3/9/123960750/2026_alca_new_brochureflyer.pdf

Big thanks go to Robert Froelich of VCA, Waganesh Zeleke of VCU, Erin Gallagher of Jay Walkers, and Daniel Birdsong of ALCA for organizing all these events.

Albuquerque — The RMACES Conference PPT Slides

Hello from beautiful Albuquerque, NM where I just landed and am patiently awaiting the availability of my hotel room so I can begin taking a substantial nap.

I was looking for fellow conference attendees on my flight from Denver to Albuquerque and, of course, found them. Given that my faith in humanity is teetering on the brink right now, it was so cool (and reassuring) to meet fellow counselor educators and feel their vibes–vibes that distinctly vibrate to the frequency of big motivation to help others lead happy, meaningful, and healthy lives. Thanks, Sharon, for initiating a conversation using your extraversion skills!

This is a small conference populated with people who have big and empathic hearts. Let’s savor that for a moment.

Speaking of savoring, I have two presentations tomorrow. The first is with Dr. Ümüt Arslan of the University of Nebraska–Kearney. Dr. Arslan is a former doc student at UM, who used to refer to himself as “the only male feminist in Turkey.” He is a magnificent person and counselor and professor and I am honored to co-present with him. Our ppts:

Tomorrow afternoon, I’m flying solo and offering a presentation titled: “The Future of Counseling is Counseling for Happiness.” To save on paper, I’m posting the ppts here:

I hope we can all grow our hearts so they metaphorically become as large as the hot air balloons floating around Albuquerque this weekend, but may they be full of empathy instead of hot air.

Chapter 3 — Resistance Busters (from Tough Kids, Cool Counseling, 2nd ed.)

The chapter linked below is from the book, Tough Kids, Cool Counseling: User-Friendly Strategies for Working with Challenging Youth. The book was published in 2007, so the language is outdated and some ways we talk about youth have changed. For example, we’re no longer comfortable with the term “Tough Kids” because referring to youth as “tough” centers the problem in them, which isn’t fair and can make change more difficult. We have a different philosophy now (please excuse the language as I make my point):

In the beginning, we thought our “tough kids” book title was clever. Sometimes Rita and I argued about who came up with our ingeniously clever title. But now we’re uncomfortable with message embedded in the title. We believe we were wrong to label youth as “tough.” There are no tough kids. There are only kids in tough situations. And one, among many tough situations young people face, is counseling. When they roll their eyes, tell us to fuck off, or refuse to talk, we shouldn’t blame them; we shouldn’t call them difficult, disturbed, or tough. Blaming young people for behaving in ways that appear defensive, obnoxious, or resistant contributes to the problem. Too often we make the mistake of thinking we’re special (we’re not) and that young people should automatically respect us (they won’t) or that they should bow to the alter of our guidance (which is as flawed as we are). Working with youth requires humility, acceptance, creativity, and compassion. We should seek to communicate to all young people who enter our space that there is no other place we’d rather be than in the room with them—without ever directly saying that there is no other place we’d rather be than in the room with them. We call that radical interest. But we’re not talking about radical interest in helping or radical interest in being competent or radical interest in social justice (all of which are great things). We’re talking about radical interest in another living, breathing, person who in this present moment, is experiencing a challenging life, part of which involves being in the room with a fucking counselor.

Not long ago, a friend called me and wanted to read me a quote from the book, “My Friends” by Fredrik Backman. He said the quote made him think of me. He read it. I loved it.

Louisa is a teenager, the best kind of human. The evidence for this is very simple: little children think teenagers are the best humans, and teenagers think teenagers are the best humans, the only people who don’t think that teenagers are the best humans are adults. Which is obviously because adults are the worst kind of humans (p. 1).

I’m honored my friend thought of me when he read this passage. I wish all teens could automatically sense that I think they’re the best humans. But unfortunately, adults are so often so dismissive and demeaning of teenagers that teenagers typically assume the opposite is true. That translates into the sad fact that if we’re going to convince teenagers we think they’re the best humans, we must do the direct and indirect work, which is not easy because we’ve been so effective—as individuals and as a society—to make teenagers think they’re the worst humans.

Here’s a link to the chapter. I hope it helps you convince teenagers they’re the best humans.

The MHA Suicide Prevention Summit is Free (up to 20 CEUs) and Coming Soon!

Why should you know about the Mental Health Academy’s annual Suicide Prevention summit?

It’s big. There are luminaries (e.g., David Jobes, Stacey Freedenthal, and Rory O’Connor). It’s free. And the MHA is an amazing Australian-based organization that gives as good as it gets. On their website, they report:

Supporting local initiatives
Through partnering with leading organizations around the world, we’ve been able to support local initiatives we’re passionate about, including helping prevent child abuse and suicide, expanding mental health services to communities in need, and more.
$1.7M given since 2009

As a part of the annual Suicide Prevention Summit, this coming Sunday, at 10:30am Eastern, August 23, 2026, I’ll be presenting. My talk is titled: “The Bad News Brain: Five Psychological Truths on Why It’s So Damn Hard to Focus on the Positive.”

Did I mention that this whole summit is free? You can get up to 20 CEUs. You can also pay $20 to have access to session recordings until October 18.

Here’s a link to the whole schedule, which begins Wednesday, August 19 at 7pm Eastern, with a presentation by David Jobes. In case you don’t know, Jobes is awesome.
https://d9hv9sikl36u8.cloudfront.net/documents/MHA-USA-SPS-2026-Schedule-V1.pdf

Not only is the live version of this event free, all the presenters also present for free.

Sometimes, when presenting online to large groups, like the Summit, it’s hard to know how the presentation is being received. This is especially true for webinar-style presentations where there’s no interaction other than the “chat feed.” The problem with using the chat feed for feedback is that it’s overwhelming. Trying to split my attention between doing my talk and reading participant comments requires repeated figure-ground shifts that render my brain dysfunctional. Consequently, I only focus on talking, ignore the feed, and wait for the illustrious Pedro Gondim to facilitate Q&R during the final 10 minutes.

Last time I presented at the Summit, a very kind, smart, and talented mental health professional I know happened to be in attendance. She wrote me a very short Dear John email:

See attached!
I have never seen anything close to this in terms of the outpouring of appreciation for you. 

All by itself, her email made my day. But she also attached the chat feed. I opened it and found a gift of 449 amazing comments. I was stunned and humbled.

This blog post is a reminder that you can still sign up for the Summit. MHA will use a portion of the funds they generate from the $20 registrants to give back to local communities. I hope to see you there—even though I won’t really see you.

Just in case you’re curious, here’s a link to the whole 449 chat feed responses (with last names of commenters deleted).


 

August is Upon Us

Historically, August was the month when psychotherapists vacationed. In that spirit, this evening I find myself at a retreat center just south of Santa Fe. Rita and I are celebrating our 40th wedding anniversary with a four-day poetry retreat.

Our retreat is with Pádraig Ó Tuama. I would have said “the amazing Pádraig Ó Tuama,” but this evening he let us know in no uncertain terms that he’s what might be called an adjective- and adverb-slayer. Meaning, he doesn’t like them and he’s inclined to kill them. He also doesn’t like repetition, which could spell trouble for me, being an academic type who likes to foreshadow what’s coming and then summarize what happened.

You can learn more about Pádraig Ó Tuama at: https://www.padraigotuama.com/

My favorite line from Pádraig’s opening comments this evening was (paraphrasing here):

If you’re projecting your resentment on me, you’re wasting your resentment.

He also said something about diagnosis and not putting lots of stock in it and suggested he didn’t much trust the solidity of identity anyway.

Tomorrow, we start at 7am. We also got a mini-lecture on punctuality. Oh my. I had no idea poetry was so disciplined. Although I’m inclined to preface the 7am start time with an adjective or two, I’ll keep this sparse, which allows you to formulate your own phenomenological projections of what my adjectives about a 7am poetry start time might have been.

It might be that this week I will also try to weave in some counseling and psychotherapy theories content into the poetry experience (and vice versa). For tonight, my thoughts turn to Chapter 1 in the brand-new 4th edition of Counseling and Psychotherapy Theories in Context and Practice. Here’s a section on “A Plan for Maximizing Positive Outcomes” in counseling/psychotherapy. How does that relate to the beginning of a 4-day poetry retreat? It seems obvious to me, but you should let me know what you think. Here’s the excerpt:

***********************************

Below, we’ve listed six ideas for maximizing positive outcomes.

  1. Emphasize the therapy relationship (J. Sommers-Flanagan & Sommers-Flanagan, 2024). Intentionally try to be genuine, accept clients for who they are, and show empathy (see Chapter 6 for more details). Consistent with Bordin’s (1979) tripartite working alliance, you should (a) establish an emotional connection with clients; (b) set mutual goals; and (c) collaborate on therapy tasks linked to therapy goals (Budge et al., 2023; J. Sommers-Flanagan, 2015; Zagorscak et al., 2020).
  2. Use flexible and culturally sensitive assessment approaches to tailor treatment to clients and their problems. As you read each chapter, you’ll see that each theory includes recommended assessment strategies. Regardless of theory, therapeutic assessment should be collaborative, empathic, and practiced with cultural humility (Finn et al., 2012; Summers & Nelson, 2023).s.
  3. Engage clients in role induction. Role induction “involves educating clients about their role and what to expect in the assessment and treatment process. When implemented well, role induction not only educates clients but also facilitates an interactive discussion about client expectation” (J. Sommers-Flanagan & Sommers-Flanagan, 2024, p. 91). Clients will do better when you discuss therapy process openly and transparently, offer them a chance to ask questions, and explain the pros and cons of specific therapy techniques.
  4. Keep up with research. Educate yourself on evidence-based relationships (Parrow, 2023), empirically supported treatments (ESTs; Harrer et al., 2025), and research-supported skills and methods (Hill & Norcross, 2023). Given the multitude of ESTs, you should learn a few for working with specific populations (e.g., if you want to work with individuals suffering from trauma, learning trauma-focused cognitive behavioral therapy, cognitive processing therapy, and/or eye movement desensitization reprocessing would be useful).
  5. To avoid negative outcomes, you should (a) continually work on self-awareness using individual supervision and peer supervision; (b) individualize therapy approaches to fit clients—rather than expecting all clients to benefit from one approach; and (c) avoid using PHTs (Lilienfeld, 2007).
  6. Use practice-based evidence or progress monitoring (PM) to track therapy process and outcomes. Practice-based evidence (aka PM) involves collecting data, sometimes every session, pertaining to client symptoms and/or client satisfaction (Meier, 2015; Sun et al., 2021). This will allow you to make modifications in your approach as needed (Lambert, 2010).

Strengths-Based Suicide for Community Medical Center in Missoula

All too early tomorrow morning I’ll be doing a couple presentations for medical staff at the Community Medical Center in Missoula. Despite the early hour, I look forward to some interesting and useful conversations with the staff. This link is to a very long ppt slide deck. It’s long because the two groups with which I will work are small, and so I will do portions of the slides depending on what the groups would like to cover. Here’s a pdf of the ppts!

The 4th Edition of Counseling and Psychotherapy Theories in Context and Practice is Now Available

Rita and I got our copies in the mail two days ago. Thanks to Bryan Cochran, the book is better than ever, and the cover is more beautiful than ever. Bryan asked Brian Christianson, a local photographer in Missoula, Montana permission to use one of his photos and, wow, it looks great.

The feeling of opening a box, getting out a book, and holding it in my hands never gets old. And, when the book has your name on it, the feelings are magnificent.

I feel like Steve Martin in the old classic film, The Jerk, when he gets a new phone book and finds his name in it.

Our books are for students in the mental health professions and mental health professionals, so they will never be bestsellers. Nevertheless, we get some sweet, meaningful, and validating feedback—which I treasure. Here’s the latest, forwarded to me by a former doctoral student at the University of Montana who is now a professor and who is already using our book (which is very kind and affirming). One of her students wrote,

“. . .let them know their text is easy to digest and has this magical ability to pull the reader in. There are moments in the first chapter where I felt like I was part of the authors’ lived experience. That feeling makes it easy to read and learn! I have enjoyed the text so far.”

Hopefully the magic will continue beyond the first chapter.

I’ll try to be more consistent in posting a few excerpts from the book on this blog. . .despite the fact that I’m not all that great at consistency! If you’re interested, you can find the text online.

Have a great weekend.

John SF

Therapy with Men and Boys

As a senior in high school, I had a chance to say a few words at the annual football awards banquet. Apparently, my stammering and stuttering through two whole minutes were so inspiring that afterward, an assistant coach took me aside and offered seven words of feedback, “You need to take a speech class.”

His words sunk in. I was a terrible and inarticulate speaker. But did I take his advice? Nope. I was too scared to even try to get better at public speaking.

Fast forward 51 years. Now I speak all the time. In one of my most recent speaking gigs, David Shepard and Erica Liebman had me on their very cool podcast called, “Therapy with Men and Boys.”

On the podcast, we talked about men and boys and therapy and suicide. We talked so much they made my appearance into two episodes. And David, whose work I respect a ton, told me, “Your comfort in front of a mic is really impressive. I can imagine how much your students liked your classes in your teaching days.” 

Thanks David! What a difference 51 years makes.

I share this story because things change with time. . .and I’m hoping (in the sociocultural-political realms) that time will change some things (for the better).

If you’re interested in therapy in general and therapy with men and boys in particular, I’m sharing links to part 1 and 2 of the podcast; they’re about 35 minutes each.

In the first part we talk about suicide in men/boys/males: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-08-40-000-male-suicides-a-year-re-thinking/id1793567491?i=1000752371768

In the second part David does a rather challenging role play with me: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-09-part-ii-on-assessing-for-suicide-with/id1793567491?i=1000758738724

Happy Easter Sunday. I hope you are being as well as you can be in these challenging times.

John

Tough Kids, Cool Counseling — In Polson, MT

Good morning.

Tammy, Dylan, and I are on our way to Polson, MT this morning to provide a 6-hour workshop on Counseling Youth.

The workshop title, “Tough Kids, Cool Counseling,” is a remnant of days gone by. Back in 1996, as Rita and I were driving from Missoula to Absarokee, we came up with that title, which we published as a book in 1997. The second edition came out in 2007.

For many years, we argued about who came up with what we considered a very nice title. I thought it was my idea. Rita thought it was hers. We were both equally shocked at each others’ claims. Have you ever had that experience with a romantic partner?

But, a few years after publishing the second edition, I gave up all claims to the title, because I suddenly realized that the title was neither nice nor cool. Constructing youth problems as “in them” was not good and not right. The title labeled the youth as “tough,” in essence, blaming them for their problems.

For the past two decades, I’ve seen youth problems differently. Now, I avoid using the phrase “Tough kids.” Instead, I advocate for framing the issues as “kids in tough life and personal situations.” I’ve decided that going to counseling is just another tough situation that many youth are forced into.

So why am I still using this title? I use it because I like to make the point–after using the phrase Tough Kids for the first five minutes–that I’ve stopped using it and that I won’t use it for the rest of the presentation and that we should all give it up together, and not even THINK about tough kids.

With that fun anecdote out of the way, I’m looking forward to a fun day of mutual learning with therapists who work for the Confederated Salish & Kootenai Tribes. And. . .here’s a pdf of the very long powerpoint slide deck.

From Chapter 2: LENSES, THEORIES, AND METHODS, OH MY!

For the 4th edition of Counseling and Psychotherapies in Context and Practice we added an amazing new author. I’ve introduced him on this blog before, but here’s his official bio for the new textbook:

Bryan Cochran, PhD., is a clinical psychologist, professor, and director of clinical training for the PhD program in clinical psychology at the University of Montana. His research areas of interest are LGBTIQ+ health and substance use treatment. He is the co-author of dozens of articles and book chapters on these issues, and 23 years into his academic career, has enjoyed being involved with this textbook project as a way of expanding his thinking and his knowledge of counseling theories and lenses. He doesn’t currently have a blog like John and Rita do but undoubtedly feels the pressure to do so every time he reads their musings on life and on their work. He works with clients in a clinical role using a variety of perspectives that you’ve read about in this text. While not at work, he loves hiking, swimming in Flathead Lake, hunting thrift and antique stores for mid-century treasures, and doing home renovations.

Working with Bryan has been nothing short of fabulous. . .in so many ways. Today, I’m featuring his introduction to the all-new Chapter 2, titled, Viewing Counseling and Psychotherapy Theories Through Contemporary Lenses. Here you go!

**********************************

LENSES, THEORIES, AND METHODS, OH MY!

Take a seat. We’d like to start this chapter with an eye (vision) examination. Or, if you prefer, think of this as an ear (hearing) exam. It’s both … and more. This chapter is a perception check.

Lenses clarify and distort. They provide more brightness or less brightness, an array of colors, and more clarity or more distortion. In this chapter, we’re not prescribing corrective lenses. If you’re familiar with an eye exam, think of the optometrist comparing lenses and repeatedly asking, “Which is clearer?” Your “vision” as a psychotherapist is as unique as your personal history and fingerprint.

This process—offering up different lenses for improving your perceptual acuity in counseling and psychotherapy—is far slower and more complex than an eye examination. But the analogy carries truth. As you try on and experiment with different lenses from this chapter, you may see your clients and their distress more accurately. You and your clients will benefit.

Lenses are different from theories. It may seem confusing, but our aim is to create a distinction that illuminates, rather than conflates, these concepts. Most therapy approaches in this book align with a particular theoretical perspective; behavioral psychotherapy is linked to theories of operant and classical conditioning. Psychoanalysis is deeply rooted in theories regarding the interplay of different mental structures, or psychodynamics. However, there’s no reason you can’t put on a queer theory lens when doing cognitive therapy, where you help a client to identify maladaptive thinking errors and discuss how those thoughts are likely to come about in a heteronormative society (one in which heterosexuality is the dominant paradigm for understanding relationships and family structures, and other configurations are seen as outside that norm). You can use lenses, such as critical race theory, queer theory, or intersectionality, to deepen your application of psychotherapy theories and tailor your treatment to a given client’s identities and needs.

New therapists often are frustrated by the need “to pick” a particular theoretical perspective, as if doing so means you’re entering an exclusive relationship with that choice. Like romantic partners, though, you’re unlikely to resonate with every aspect of every theoretical perspective. Unlike with a romantic partner (unless you’re setting yourself up for a series of arguments), you can analyze theoretical perspectives through various lenses to separate the parts of the theories that are most useful from those that are less useful.

So, what do we mean by a lens, in comparison to a theory? Lenses transcend disciplines—they often emerge outside of psychology but can be applied to psychological theories. Whereas a theory might tell you what to do as a therapist—what to assess, how to intervene—a lens informs how you go about doing it. Because a lens transforms how you view the world, you might adopt (or already have adopted!) a lens without being aware of it. Since one of the key principles of counseling is to understand what biases we bring into the therapeutic process, spending time talking about key lenses in a chapter new to this edition seemed like a good idea to us.

As you adapt a particular lens for viewing a counseling theory, it may be tempting to throw out the history and background of that theory because it doesn’t stand the test of time. A good example of this is the waves of critiques that have been leveled against Freudian psychoanalysis. While there are few current theorists who would say young women suffer from castration anxiety or that the Oedipal complex is a major influence on young men, the idea that some of the determinants of our behavior operate outside of our consciousness remains robust, supported by empirical research and lived experience. We believe it’s possible to hold onto both a lens and a theory at the same time. Let’s spend some time exploring some different lenses for viewing counseling and therapy so you can further develop your sense of who you might be as an emerging clinician.